Hiring guides
Practical advice for people who don't hire for a living.
Guides
- The executive director search process, step by step
A confidential, ten-step plan for boards hiring their top leader without leaking names or losing candidates. - Interim executive director: a guide for boards
When a board needs an interim leader, what the role covers, how to find one, and what to put in the agreement. - How to form a search committee
Who chairs, how many members, who to include, and a sample written charge for your board to approve. - The search committee checklist
Everything a volunteer committee needs to decide before the job posting goes live, and after. - How to do blind resume review on a small team
Why hiding names in the first pass leads to better decisions, and how to set it up in an afternoon. - Interview questions for executive director and CEO candidates
Thirty questions organized by what the board needs to learn, with what a strong answer sounds like. - Executive director job description template
A free, editable template your board can adapt in an hour, with notes on what to include and what to skip. - A scoring rubric for executive director candidates
A weighted rubric your search committee can build in one meeting, with a 1 to 5 scale and rules for using it fairly. - How long does an executive director search take?
A realistic week-by-week timeline for board search committees, from forming the committee to the new leader's first day. - Reference check questions for executive director candidates
Twenty-one questions for your finalists' references, plus who to call, when to call, and how to read what you hear. - How to announce your executive director is leaving
A communication plan for the board: who to tell first, sample staff and donor announcements, and how to keep the search confidential. - Search committee confidentiality agreement template
A one-page, plain-language agreement every committee member signs at the first meeting, with notes on each section. - Executive director onboarding plan: the board's first 90 days
A practical 90-day plan for welcoming a new executive director: before day one, the first week, check-ins, introductions, and first-year goals. - Internal candidates in an executive director search
How the board keeps the search fair when a staff member applies: the first conversation, conflicts on the committee, and what to say if they are not chosen. - Candidate rejection email templates for executive director searches
Six templates for telling candidates no at every stage of a board search, a phone script for finalists, and when to send each one. - Executive search firm or run it yourself? A guide for nonprofit boards
What a search firm does and costs, when a board can run its own executive director search, a hybrid option, and how to decide in one meeting.