Search committee software for nonprofit boards
Your board is hiring its next CEO or executive director. The committee is volunteers with day jobs, the stakes are high, and confidentiality is not optional. SealedApply gives the committee one private place to run the whole search.
The problem with running a search out of someone's inbox
Most committees start the same way: resumes go to the chair's email, someone builds a spreadsheet, and attachments get forwarded to six personal inboxes. A month later nobody is sure which version of the shortlist is current, sensitive files are scattered across accounts nobody controls, and the decision comes down to whoever spoke last in the meeting.
How a search committee works in SealedApply
- One apply link. Post it in your job announcement, on your website, and on LinkedIn. Candidates apply once, without creating an account.
- Sealed applications. Resumes and cover letters are stored encrypted. Only the committee members you invite can open them, and files are never sent as email attachments.
- Everyone weighs in. Each member rates applicants and leaves notes. Averages are shown, and split votes are flagged so you discuss them before you decide.
- Stages the whole committee can see. Move people through New, Reviewing, Interview, Finalist, and Offer so the shortlist is never out of date.
- A shared scorecard. Turn one on and every member scores each applicant on the same criteria, starting from your must-haves. Criteria where the committee splits are highlighted.
- Blind first pass. Turn on blind review to hide names and contact details while the committee forms first impressions. It carries into interview emails, where members see a candidate number instead of a name.
- Interviews without the reply-all. On paid searches, members mark when they're free and candidates book a time from a link, with calendar invites for everyone. Candidates can reschedule on their own.
- An AI hiring advisor. On paid searches, each application is read against your job description and gets a summary, strengths and gaps, a fit score, and three interview questions. It is advice. The committee decides.
- Less email. Members can get one daily summary of new applications instead of a message for each one.
Built for confidential searches
Candidates for a top job are often employed somewhere else, and a leak can cost you your best applicant. Applications are visible only to the people you invite. Staff do not see them. SealedApply employees do not look unless you ask us for help. Candidate questions go to the contact you choose, and every applicant gets a confirmation in your organization's name. Read our guide to running a confidential executive search.
Board portal or hiring tool?
Search for "search committee software" and most of what comes up is board management software: board portals for meeting agendas, minutes, board packets, votes, and committee documents. Those tools are good at running a board. A search committee could store its documents there, but a portal is not built to run a hire.
A hiring search has jobs a board portal usually does not do: taking applications from people outside the organization, replying to each applicant, tracking where every candidate stands, collecting each member's ratings before the meeting, scheduling interviews with candidates, and deleting application files when the search is over. Many boards use both: the portal for the board's own business, and a hiring tool for the search itself.
| The search committee needs to | Board portal | SealedApply |
|---|---|---|
| Share meeting agendas, minutes, and board packets | Yes, its main job | No, keep using your portal or email |
| Take applications from outside candidates through one link | Usually not | Yes, no applicant account needed |
| Confirm each application in your organization's name | Usually not | Yes, automatically |
| Rate and comment on each candidate, independently first | Usually not | Yes |
| Track every candidate's stage | Usually not | Yes |
| Let candidates book interviews when the committee is free | Usually not | Yes, on paid searches |
| Delete application files on a schedule after the search | Usually not | Yes |
If your board already pays for a portal, keep it for the board's work. Use it for the committee's charge, minutes, and the final recommendation, and run the candidates through a tool made for hiring.
What to look for in search committee software
Most hiring software is built for human resources teams that hire every week, and most search committee tools are built for universities. A volunteer board committee hiring its executive director needs something different. Whatever you choose, check for these:
- Access by invitation only. Applications should be visible only to the people on the committee, not to staff, the rest of the board, or anyone with the link.
- No per-seat pricing. A committee of seven should not cost seven licenses. SealedApply includes unlimited reviewers on every plan.
- Independent ratings. Members should be able to rate each applicant before they see how others rated, so the first read is their own.
- Nothing for applicants to sign up for. Senior candidates who are quietly exploring will not create an account to apply. In SealedApply they fill in one form.
- Easy for volunteers. If committee members need training to use it, they will go back to email. Look for something a board member can learn in one sitting.
- A clean ending. When the search is over, you should be able to delete application files, not leave them sitting in personal inboxes.
Before the first application arrives
Software helps most when the committee is set up well. If your board is just starting, read how to form a search committee for choosing the chair and members and writing the charge, then use the search committee checklist to get ready to post.
Common questions
Can we run the search in our board portal?
You can store the committee's documents there, such as the charge, the job description, and meeting minutes. Board portals are built for board meetings, so most do not take applications from outside candidates, confirm each application, track candidate stages, or schedule interviews. Many boards keep the portal for board business and run the candidates through a hiring tool.
Can committee members see each other's ratings?
Yes, after they rate. Each member rates applicants from 1 to 5 and leaves notes. A member sees the committee's ratings for an applicant once they have added their own, so everyone's first read is independent. Search owners can always see them. Ratings are averaged, and split votes are flagged so the committee talks them through.
Can board members who are not on the committee see applications?
No. Only the people you invite to the search can open applications. Staff, other board members, and SealedApply employees cannot see them unless you invite them or ask us for help.
Do applicants need to create an account?
No. Applicants use the link you share, fill in one form, and get a confirmation email written in your organization's name.
Is AI making the hiring decision?
No. On paid searches the AI hiring advisor summarizes each application and suggests who to talk to first. Every decision is made by a person on your committee.
Keep reading