Reference check questions for executive director candidates
References are the last chance to test what your committee learned in interviews. Here is when to call, who to call, the questions to ask, and how to tell a polite reference from a warning.
Why references matter more for an executive director
An executive director reports to a board that sees them a few hours a month. Interviews show you how a candidate presents. References show you how they work when nobody from the board is in the room: with staff, with donors, with a budget that is not adding up, and with a board chair who disagrees. That is most of the job.
Most references are positive. Candidates choose people who will speak well of them, and many employers have a policy of confirming only dates and job titles. So the goal is not to catch a lie. It is to get specific examples that confirm, or complicate, what your committee already believes.
When to check references
Call references for your top one or two finalists, after the final interview round and before the committee brings a recommendation to the board. In a typical executive director search timeline that is about weeks 14 to 15.
- Ask the candidate first. Tell finalists when you will start calling, and confirm who they want you to contact.
- Never call a current employer without permission. Many finalists have not told their current board they are looking. One call can cost them their job and cost you your candidate. Our guide to running a confidential executive search covers this in more detail.
- Allow a week. References are busy people, and some calls take several tries to schedule.
Who to ask for
Ask each finalist for three to five references who saw their work from different sides:
- Someone they reported to. For a current or former executive director, that is a board chair or board member. For a deputy, it is their executive director.
- Someone who reported to them. A senior staff member who worked for them for at least a year.
- A peer or external partner. A funder, a partner organization's leader, or a fellow executive.
If a candidate cannot offer anyone they reported to, or anyone who reported to them, ask why. There is often a good answer, but you should hear it.
Before you call: prepare from your rubric
Do not walk into a reference call with general questions. Take the criteria from your scoring rubric and the notes from the finalist interviews, and write down the two or three things you still need to confirm about this candidate. Spend most of each call there. The questions below are a menu to choose from, not a script to read in full.
Opening the call
- How do you know the candidate, for how long, and in what role?
- What was the organization trying to accomplish while you worked together?
- What were they responsible for, and what did they take on beyond that?
Listen for: how close the reference really was to the work. A board member who met them quarterly knows less than a deputy who worked beside them daily.
Leadership and staff
- How would their staff describe them as a manager?
- Tell me about a time they had to manage a performance problem. What did they do?
- Who did they hire or develop who went on to do well?
- How did staff turnover change while they led the team?
Listen for: named people and concrete outcomes. "Everyone loved working for them" tells you less than one specific story.
Board partnership
- How did they keep the board informed, and how did they handle bad news?
- Tell me about a time they disagreed with the board. How did it get resolved?
- How did they work with board members on fundraising or community relationships?
- If you were their board chair again, what would you ask them to do differently?
Listen for: whether bad news reached the board early and plainly, and whether disagreements ended in a decision both sides could live with.
Fundraising and money
- What was their personal role in the organization's largest gifts or grants?
- How did they handle a year when revenue fell short?
- How well did they understand the budget and the financial statements?
Listen for: personal ownership. "The development team did great work" and "they personally ran that relationship for three years" are different answers.
Judgment and pressure
- Tell me about the hardest decision you saw them make. How did they make it?
- Describe a mistake they made and what they did afterward.
- How did they behave when they were under the most pressure?
Closing questions
- What kind of organization or board would they struggle with?
- What support would help them succeed in their first year with us?
- Would you hire or work with them again? Why?
- Is there anything I have not asked that you think we should know?
Listen for: hesitation on question 20. A quick, warm "yes, in a heartbeat" sounds different from "well, in the right role." Ask what the right role would be.
How to read what you hear
- Faint praise is information. When a reference who should know the candidate well offers only general compliments, ask for one example. If they cannot give one, note it.
- Look for patterns, not single comments. One reference with a concern may be one bad relationship. The same concern from two people who do not know each other deserves a follow-up conversation with the candidate.
- Give the candidate a chance to respond. If something worries you, ask the finalist about it directly. How they answer is often as useful as the concern itself.
- Write it down the same day. Use the same note format for every call: who, their relationship, what they confirmed, what raised a question, and direct quotes for anything important.
Keep it fair and job-related
Ask every reference for every finalist about the same areas, and keep questions tied to the job. Do not ask about age, health, family plans, religion, or other personal characteristics, and stop the reference if they start offering that kind of detail. If you also run a formal background check through an outside company, the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act requires the candidate's written permission first; the Federal Trade Commission's guide, Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know, explains the basics. When in doubt, check with your organization's counsel.
Bringing references back to the committee
Share the written notes with every committee member before the decision meeting, so nobody hears them for the first time in the room. Then rescore each finalist on your rubric with the reference evidence in hand. References rarely change a committee's top choice, but when they do, it is usually because two or three people independently described the same problem.
Keeping finalist notes private in SealedApply
SealedApply gives a search committee one private place to run the search, including the final stretch. Only the people you invite to the search can open applications. Each member rates finalists from 1 to 5 and leaves notes, so reference findings can sit next to the interview notes for the same candidate. Ratings are averaged and split votes are flagged, and candidates move through stages the whole committee can see, from New to Finalist to Offer. When the hire is made, you can email the other applicants in bulk to let them know they were not selected.
Common questions
How many references should we check for an executive director?
Three to five for each finalist, and only for your top one or two candidates. Include at least one person the candidate reported to, ideally a board chair, and at least one person who reported to them.
Can we contact references the candidate did not list?
Only with the candidate's permission. Calls to people outside the list, sometimes called backchannel references, can reveal a confidential job search to a current employer. Ask the candidate first, and agree on who you may call.
When should a board check references?
After finalist interviews and before the board votes. Checking earlier wastes the references' goodwill on candidates you will not hire; checking after the vote turns a red flag into an awkward reversal.
Who on the search committee should make reference calls?
Two members, ideally the same two for every finalist, so the notes are comparable. One asks the questions and one takes notes. Share the notes with the full committee in writing before it meets to decide.
Is a reference check the same as a background check?
No. A reference check is a conversation about how the candidate works. A background check verifies records such as employment dates, education, or criminal history. If you use a background check company, federal law requires the candidate's written permission first, and your state may add its own rules.
Keep reading