How to form a search committee
The committee your board forms in the first two weeks shapes the whole executive director search. Here is how to pick the chair and members, and how to write the charge that tells them what to do.
Form it early, and form it on purpose
Once the board knows the executive director is leaving, the search committee should be one of its first decisions. Waiting costs time you will want later, and committees put together in a hurry tend to be whoever was free that week. Treat it as a board decision: the board chair proposes a chair and members, and the full board approves them together with a written charge.
If you have not yet told staff and donors about the transition, plan that first. Our guide to announcing that your executive director is leaving covers the order and the wording.
Choose the chair first
The chair does more work than anyone else on the committee. They run meetings, keep the timeline, are the single point of contact for candidates, and report to the board. Look for someone who:
- Has the time. Plan for several hours a week at the busiest points of the search.
- Is trusted by the rest of the board, including members who see the organization's future differently.
- Can run a meeting where people disagree and still reach a decision.
- Can keep a confidence, and will hold others to it.
The board chair can lead the search committee, but it is often better if they do not. The board chair already carries the transition, the interim plan, and the relationship with staff. A separate search chair spreads the load, and the board chair can still join the committee as a member.
Decide how many members
Five to seven members works for most nonprofit boards. Fewer than that and the work falls on one or two people; more than that and scheduling gets hard, conversations get longer, and confidentiality gets harder to keep. Smaller boards can run a good search with three or four people. You do not need an odd number: a search committee recommends, the board decides, and a committee that is evenly split has more talking to do, not a tie to break.
Decide who belongs on it
Pick members for what they bring to this particular search, not for seniority or availability alone. A good committee usually includes:
- Board members who will still be serving when the new leader starts, so the people who chose them are the people who work with them.
- A mix of perspectives on the job: someone strong on finance, someone close to fundraising, someone close to programs or the community you serve.
- Different views of the organization's future. If the board has a real disagreement about direction, settle it before the search or make sure both sides are represented. Otherwise it resurfaces at the final vote.
- Someone with hiring experience, if your board has one. They do not need to be in human resources; anyone who has hired a senior leader before will help.
Some groups need a deliberate decision rather than a default:
- Staff. A senior staff member brings knowledge of what the job really involves, but they would be choosing their own boss, and confidentiality is harder to keep. Many boards give staff a defined role instead, such as meeting the finalists, rather than a vote on the committee.
- The outgoing executive director. Ask for their help with the job description and a briefing, and keep them off the committee. Choosing the successor is the board's job.
- Outside advisors. A community leader or a former executive director can add perspective. If you include one, they sign the same confidentiality agreement as everyone else.
- Possible candidates. Anyone who might apply, including a board member or an internal leader, should not serve on the committee. Ask about this directly at the first meeting. See internal candidates in an executive director search.
Write the committee's charge
The charge is a short document the board approves that tells the committee what it is responsible for, what authority it has, and when it is done. It prevents the most common search arguments: who decides, who may see candidates, and what the committee was supposed to deliver. Copy this sample and replace the bracketed text.
Charge to the [Executive Director / CEO] Search Committee of [Organization name]
Purpose. The committee will lead the search for [Organization name]'s next [Executive Director / CEO] and recommend [one candidate / up to three finalists] to the board.
Members. [Name], chair; [Names], members. The committee may ask others to help with specific tasks but may not add voting members without board approval.
Responsibilities. The committee will: confirm the priorities for the role with the board; prepare the job description and posting; decide where to advertise; review applications; interview candidates; check references with each finalist's permission; and present its recommendation with the reasons for it.
Authority. The committee [may / may not] engage a search consultant [within the budget the board has approved]. The committee may not make an offer or discuss final compensation without board approval. The board will vote on the hire.
Confidentiality. Every member signs the search committee confidentiality agreement before reviewing any application. Candidate names are shared with the full board only [at the finalist stage / with the final recommendation].
Reporting. The chair will update the board on progress, without naming candidates, at each board meeting and when the committee reaches each stage of the search.
Timeline. The committee will aim to recommend a candidate by [date].
Ending. The committee's work ends when the board votes on the hire, or earlier if the board decides. Members will return or delete search materials at that point.
For the confidentiality agreement every member signs, start from our search committee confidentiality agreement template.
Agenda for the first meeting
- Read the charge together and answer questions about it.
- Sign the confidentiality agreement.
- Ask each member to disclose any relationship with a likely candidate, and whether they might apply.
- Agree on the three to five priorities the next leader must deliver. Everything later, from the job description to the scoring rubric, comes from these.
- Set a draft timeline. Our executive director search timeline gives a week-by-week starting point.
- Agree how the committee will communicate and where applications will live, before the posting goes out.
- Assign owners: who drafts the job description, who handles candidate questions, who takes notes.
Mistakes to avoid
- No written charge. Without one, the committee and the board can each believe they are the ones deciding.
- A committee of whoever volunteered. Ask for the members you need, and explain why you asked them.
- Applications in someone's inbox. Resumes forwarded among personal email accounts are hard to keep confidential and impossible to clean up later. See why collecting resumes by email causes problems.
- Group reading before individual rating. If members discuss candidates before they have each formed their own view, the loudest opinion tends to win. Rate independently first, then meet.
Giving the committee one place to work
SealedApply is built for volunteer search committees. You share one apply link, and applications arrive in a private list that only the people you invite can open. Each member rates applicants and leaves notes, and sees the committee's ratings once they have added their own, so first reads stay independent. You can turn on blind review for the first pass, and members can get one daily summary instead of an email for every application. See how it works for search committees.
Common questions
How many people should be on a search committee?
Five to seven works for most nonprofit boards. That is enough to bring different perspectives and share the work, and small enough to schedule meetings, keep the search confidential, and reach agreement. Smaller boards can run a good search with three or four members.
Should staff serve on the executive director search committee?
It depends on your organization. A senior staff member can help the committee understand what the job really requires, but they will be reviewing a future boss, and confidentiality is harder to keep. Many boards keep the voting committee to board members and give staff a defined role instead, such as meeting finalists or answering questions about operations.
Should the outgoing executive director be on the committee?
Usually not. Their knowledge of the role is valuable, so ask them to help with the job description and to brief the committee. Choosing a successor is the board's responsibility, and candidates speak more freely when their predecessor is not in the room.
Does the search committee hire the executive director?
In most nonprofits, no. The committee runs the search and recommends one or more finalists. The full board votes to hire, as its bylaws require. Write this into the committee's charge so nobody is unsure who decides.
Do we need a search firm?
Not always. A search firm can help with recruiting, especially for large or hard-to-fill roles. Many smaller organizations run their own search with a well-organized committee. Either way, the committee still does the core work: setting priorities, reviewing candidates, and recommending a hire.
Keep reading