Executive search firm or run it yourself? A guide for nonprofit boards
One of the first decisions a board makes when its executive director leaves is whether to hire a search firm. Both routes can end with a great leader. Here is what a firm actually does, when a board can run its own search, a hybrid option that many boards overlook, and how to decide in one meeting.
What an executive search firm does
A good search firm brings experience, reach, and structure. A typical retained search covers:
- Discovery. Interviews with board members, staff, and sometimes funders to understand what the organization needs next.
- The position profile. A polished document describing the organization, the role, and the qualifications, which doubles as your posting.
- Recruiting. Reaching people who are not looking. Many of the strongest candidates already lead an organization and will only consider a move if someone calls them.
- Screening. First-round conversations, so the committee meets a short list instead of reading every application.
- Process management. Scheduling, candidate communication, and keeping the committee on its timeline.
- References and the offer. Deeper reference checks, and help with compensation and negotiation.
What a firm does not do is make the decision. The board still sets the priorities, interviews the finalists, and votes. A firm also does not remove the committee's work: expect the same number of committee meetings, just with better-prepared material at each one.
What a firm costs
Retained search firms usually charge a fee tied to the role's first-year cash compensation, commonly around a third of it, paid in installments as the search moves forward, plus expenses such as travel and background checks. For many small and mid-sized nonprofits, that is one of the largest single expenses of the year.
Some firms that specialize in smaller nonprofits offer flat fees or lighter packages. Before you compare firms, ask each one the same questions:
- What is the total fee, and when is each installment due?
- What expenses are billed on top?
- Who will actually run our search day to day?
- What happens if we do not hire anyone, or if the person we hire leaves within the first year?
- How many searches like ours have you completed in the last two years?
When a search firm is worth it
- The role is hard to fill. A specialized field, a large budget, a turnaround, or a location where few qualified people live.
- Nobody on the board has the time. A self-run search needs a committee chair who can give it several hours a week for four months or more. If that person does not exist, a firm is cheaper than a failed search.
- The board is divided. After a difficult departure, a neutral outsider can run interviews, gather input, and keep the process fair in a way a board member cannot.
- You need people who are not looking. If your best candidates are sitting leaders at peer organizations, a firm's calls and relationships matter.
- You have tried before. If a self-run search already stalled once, bring in help for the second attempt.
When a board can run its own search
- You have a committed chair and a working committee. Five to seven people who will show up, read applications, and keep names confidential. Our guide to forming a search committee covers who to include and how to write the charge.
- Your network is strong. Local leaders, partners, and funders already know your organization and will pass the posting along.
- The role is well understood. You know what the next leader needs to do, and you can write it down in a clear job description.
- The budget is tight. The fee you save can go toward a fair salary, which matters more to candidates than who ran the search.
- You have a written process. A self-run search succeeds or fails on structure: a timeline, a rubric, independent scoring, and a plan for confidentiality. The executive director search process lays out every step.
The hybrid option
Many boards treat this as all or nothing. It does not have to be. Consultants and some firms offer pieces of a search, and the board does the rest. Common splits:
| Bring in help for | The committee handles | Works well when |
|---|---|---|
| Discovery and the position profile | Posting, screening, interviews, references | The board is unsure what the next leader should focus on |
| Recruiting and sourcing candidates | Screening, interviews, references | Your own network will not reach enough strong candidates |
| Facilitating the committee | All candidate work | The committee is capable but needs a neutral chair for hard conversations |
| Reference and background checks | Everything else | You want an outside, consistent read on the finalists |
| Compensation and the offer | Everything else | The board has not set an executive salary in years |
A partial package can cost much less than a full retained search, and it puts outside help exactly where your committee is weakest.
How to decide in one board meeting
Put these five questions on the agenda and answer each one honestly:
- Who will chair the search, and do they have four to six months of steady time? If nobody can say yes, lean toward a firm.
- Where will the strongest candidates come from? If the answer is "people we already know," you may not need a firm to find them.
- Is the board aligned on what the next leader must do? If not, pay for discovery and facilitation even if you run the rest.
- What can we spend? Compare a firm's full fee with what the same money would do for the salary or for the interim period. If you need an interim leader while you search, see our interim executive director guide.
- How confidential does this need to be? Either route can protect candidates. A self-run search needs clear rules on who sees applications and a signed confidentiality agreement.
Record the decision and the reasons in the minutes. If you choose a firm, interview at least two or three, check their references with boards they have worked for, and agree on the timeline in writing. Either way, our search timeline shows what a realistic schedule looks like.
If you run it yourself: what makes it work
- One owner. The committee chair runs the calendar, the agenda, and candidate communication.
- Meetings booked in advance. Put every committee meeting and interview day on the calendar at the start. Searches stall on scheduling far more often than on candidates.
- A rubric before applications arrive. Agree on what you are scoring and how, using a weighted scoring rubric.
- Independent review first. Each member scores on their own before the committee discusses, so the loudest voice does not set the list.
- A plan to tell people no. Decide who sends decline emails and when. Our rejection email templates cover each stage.
- One place for everything. Applications in a shared inbox, scores in a spreadsheet, and notes in email threads are how names leak and candidates get lost.
Running your search in SealedApply
SealedApply is built for boards and small teams that hire a few times a year. You get a branded apply page, and every application lands in one place with a confirmation email to the candidate. The search owner invites committee members by email, with unlimited reviewers on every plan. Each member rates applicants, leaves notes, and moves them through stages. Turn on blind review to hide names and personal details during the first pass. On paid searches, the hiring advisor gives each application a summary, a score, and suggested interview questions, and committee members mark when they are free so finalists can book their own interviews. Scores are advice only; the committee makes every decision.
If you use a consultant for part of the search, you can invite them to the search as a reviewer like any committee member, so the whole group works from the same page. Your first search is free with up to 25 applicants, and a paid search is $99 per hire. See how it works for search committees.
Common questions
Do we need a search firm to hire an executive director?
No. Many boards run their own executive director search with a well-organized committee, a written plan, and a few months of steady volunteer time. A firm is most worth it when the role is hard to fill, the board has no one with time to manage the process, or the search needs a neutral outsider.
How much does an executive search firm cost?
Retained search firms usually charge a fee tied to the role's first-year cash compensation, commonly around a third of it, paid in installments during the search, plus expenses. Some firms that focus on smaller nonprofits offer flat fees or lighter packages. Ask every firm for its full fee, what it includes, and what happens if the search fails.
What is the difference between a retained and a contingency search firm?
A retained firm is paid in stages to run the whole search for you, whether or not you hire one of its candidates. A contingency firm is paid only if you hire someone it introduced. Most executive director searches that use a firm use a retained one.
Does a search firm make the hiring decision?
No. A firm recruits, screens, and advises, but the board sets the priorities, interviews the finalists, and votes on the hire. That is true whichever route you choose.
Can a board use a firm for only part of the search?
Yes. Some consultants offer a partial package, such as writing the position profile and recruiting candidates while the committee runs screening and interviews, or only running reference checks. This can cost much less than a full retained search.
Keep reading