Interview questions for executive director and CEO candidates
Use these with your search committee. Pick five or six per round, ask every candidate the same ones, and rate answers against the priorities you agreed on before the search began.
How to use these questions
Most board searches hold two or three rounds. Plan which questions belong in each one before the first interview, and write them into the committee's interview guide.
| Round | Length | What to cover |
|---|---|---|
| Screening call | 20 to 30 minutes | Two or three questions on motivation and must-haves, plus logistics like timing and salary range |
| First-round interview | 60 to 75 minutes | Five or six questions across strategy, fundraising, finance, and leading people |
| Finalist interview | Half a day or more | Board partnership, judgment, and a short presentation, plus time with staff and the full board |
Ask every candidate in a round the same questions in the same order, so the committee compares answers rather than conversations. Follow-up questions are fine: "What did you do next?" and "What would you do differently?" usually tell you more than the first answer.
Vision and strategy
- What did you learn about our organization while preparing, and what would you want to understand better in your first 90 days?
- Tell us about a strategy you set that changed direction partway through. What made you change course?
- Where do you see the biggest opportunity for an organization like ours over the next three years?
- How do you decide what to stop doing?
Listen for: curiosity before conclusions, specific examples, and a willingness to say no.
Red flag: a ready-made plan for your organization before they have talked to anyone who works there.
Fundraising and revenue
- Walk us through the largest gift or partnership you personally secured. What was your role at each step?
- How have you grown revenue from a source that was not working when you arrived?
- How do you involve board members in fundraising who are uncomfortable asking for money?
- What is the right mix of revenue for an organization our size, and why?
Listen for: personal ownership of relationships, numbers they can recall, and respect for donors as partners.
Red flag: "we raised" with no clear answer to "and what did you do?" Ask for their part at each step.
Financial stewardship
- Describe a time you had to cut a budget. How did you decide, and how did you tell people?
- Which three numbers would you look at every month, and why those?
- Tell us about a financial problem you found that others had missed.
Listen for: comfort with financial statements and honesty about hard tradeoffs.
Red flag: treating finance as the finance staff's job alone. The executive director answers to the board for the budget.
Leading people
- Tell us about someone you developed who now leads at a higher level.
- Describe a time you had to let someone go. What did you learn?
- How would your current team describe your leadership on a hard day?
- How do you build a team that can run without you for a month?
- What do you do in your first month with a staff that is wary of a new leader?
Listen for: credit given to others, accountability, and succession thinking.
Red flag: every hard staff story ends with someone else at fault.
Partnering with the board
- What does a great board chair relationship look like to you, week to week?
- Tell us about a time you disagreed with your board. How was it resolved?
- What should the board decide, and what should it leave to you?
- How do you keep a board informed without overwhelming it?
Listen for: clear roles, candor, and no surprises.
Red flag: describing past boards only as obstacles, or saying they have never disagreed with one.
Community and external relationships
- Who are the first ten people you would meet in our community, and why?
- Tell us about a partnership you built that lasted after you left.
- How do you represent an organization in a room where people disagree with each other?
Listen for: genuine relationships, not name-dropping.
Red flag: a list of important names with no story about what they built together.
Culture, inclusion, and judgment
- How have you made it easier for people with different views to be heard on your team?
- Tell us about a decision you made with incomplete information. How did it turn out?
- Describe a mistake you made as a leader and what you changed afterward.
- What would make you leave a job like this one?
Listen for: mistakes owned plainly, with a specific change afterward.
Red flag: a "mistake" that is really a strength, such as working too hard.
Closing questions
- What would you want to accomplish in your first year that you would be proud to report to us?
- What support would you need from the board to succeed?
- What have we not asked that we should know about you?
For finalists: a short presentation
A finalist round often includes a 15 to 20 minute presentation followed by questions. Give every finalist the same prompt and the same materials a week ahead, for example:
"Using our most recent annual report and budget summary, tell us what you would want to learn in your first 90 days, who you would meet first, and what you would bring back to the board at the end of that time."
Keep the prompt about how they think, not a free consulting project. Share only public or non-sensitive materials, and ask finalists to treat them as confidential anyway.
Questions finalists will ask you
Strong candidates interview the board too. Agree on honest answers before the finalist round, especially to these:
- Why did the last executive director leave?
- What is the organization's financial position, including reserves and any deficit?
- How does the board give to and raise money for the organization?
- What would the board want to see in the first year?
- Is there an internal candidate? (If there is, see internal candidates in an executive director search.)
- How will the board review the executive director's performance?
Questions to avoid
Keep every question tied to the job. Do not ask about age, marital status, children or plans for children, religion, national origin, health or disability, or anything else unrelated to the work. If a candidate brings one of these up, do not follow it with more questions. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission publishes guidance on prohibited practices, and state laws can add more. Ask your counsel if you are unsure about a question.
Tips for the committee
- Agree on the questions and who asks each one before the interview.
- Have every member rate each answer independently, then compare. A shared scoring rubric keeps everyone on the same criteria.
- Take notes on what the candidate said, not your impression of them. "Grew individual giving from two donors to forty" is useful later. "Seemed great" is not.
- Leave at least 15 minutes for the candidate's questions. What they ask tells you a lot.
- Tell every candidate when they will hear back, then keep that promise. Our rejection email templates cover each round.
Common questions
How many interview questions should we ask an executive director candidate?
Five or six in a 60 to 75 minute first-round interview, with time for follow-up questions and at least 15 minutes for the candidate's own questions. Finalist rounds are longer and can cover more.
Should every candidate get the same questions?
Yes, within a round. Asking everyone the same questions in the same order lets the committee compare answers fairly and score them against the same criteria.
Who should ask the questions?
Assign each question to one committee member before the interview. The chair opens, explains the format, and keeps time. Everyone takes notes and rates answers independently.
Should we interview an internal candidate the same way?
Yes. Use the same questions and the same scoring. Ask how they would lead as the top executive, not about their current job.
Keep reading